THE ORIGINAL OHIO STYLE PIZZA

Round pie, square-cut, cheese to the edge, mid-thickness crust, finished with our signature Ohio Style sweet sauce and a garlic oil drizzle on top of the pie (no sauce under the cheese)

BUILD YOUR OWN PIE

REGULAR TOPPINGS
$1 / $2 / $3

Pepperoni
Thick-sliced Pep
Crumbled Sausage
Sliced Sausage
Meatball
Ham
Bacon
Salami
Spinach
Tomato
Pineapple

VEGAN TOPPINGS
$2 / $3 / $4

Vegan Cheese Blend
Vegan Chicken
Vegan Sausage
Vegan Pepperoni
Vegan Party Sauce

SPECIALTY PIES
S $14 / M $19 / L $24

THE HEART OF IT ALL
(Deluxe)

Pepperoni, crumbled sausage,
mushroom, onion, green pepper

HEARTBURNER
(Super Pepperoni)

Pepperoni, thick-sliced pepperoni,
extra cheese, extra garlic oil

FANCY PEP
(Pep, But Fancy!)

World’s best pepperoni, ricotta,
Nick’s Hot Honey

FIREBIRD
(Buffalo Chicken)

Our signature buffalo chicken mix
(think buffalo chicken dip—
chicken, buffalo sauce,
party sauce, bleu cheese)

PIGGY BIRD
(BBQ Chicken)

Chicken, barbecue sauce, bacon,
crispy french-fried onions

BURLY BOY (MEAT)

Pepperoni, crumbled sausage,
meatball, bacon, salami

SAUSAGE & PEPPERS
(You Get The Point)

Sliced sausage, crumbled sausage,
giardiniera, sweet peppers

BASIC B (White Pizza)

Party sauce (white sauce),
cheese blend, spinach, ricotta

PARADISE (Hawaiian)

Pineapple (grow up, it’s good),
ham, bacon

BIO-DOME (Veggie)

Mushroom, onion, green pepper, black olive, banana pepper

NICK’S PICK

You get what you get - let it rip (changes regularly)

VEGAN SPECIALTY PIES
S $14 / M $20 / L $26

*All vegan specialty pies made with vegan cheese blend

VEGAN FIREBIRD

Buffalo sauce, Vegan Party Sauce,
vegan buffalo chicken

VEGAN BIO-DOME

Standard Bio-Dome w/vegan cheese

VEGAN HEART OF IT ALL

Our vegan deluxe...$14/21/28

THE KENNEDY

Extra vegan sausage,
peppadew peppers

EARTH CRISIS

Vegan Party Sauce, spinach, tomatoes

VEGAN PIGGY BIRD

BBQ sauce, vegan BBQ chicken,
crispy onions

PARTY BREAD
S $11 / M $15 / L $19

AVAILABLE VEGAN!
S $12 / M $16 / L $20

Cheesy garlic bread made on our pizza dough served with a side of red sauce.
*Same size as our pizzas

BRUNCH PIES
S $14 / M $19 / L $24

SERVED EVERY SATURDAY & SUNDAY 9AM-NOON

All brunch pies made with our signature “everything” crust and our cream cheese-based white sauce (Party Sauce). Topped with our cheese blend, scrambled eggs and garlic oil.

THE DEFONTE

Potato, egg, cheese

THE SNOOZE BUTTON

Egg, onion, green pepper,
ham, mushroom

GOOD MORNING

Extra egg, cheese

THE BODEGA

Bacon, egg, cheese

THE UNCLE TONY

Peppadews, egg, cheese

NOT-SO-MEDIOCRE SALADS
(Add Chicken - $3)

CLASSIC PIZZA
SHOP SALAD - $8

Iceberg lettuce, too much cheese, tomato

ANTIPASTO - $10

Iceberg lettuce, cheese, tomato, olive, banana pepper, ham, salami, pepperoni

CRISPY PEP SALAD - $10

Iceberg lettuce, cheese, peppadews, tomato, Crispy World’s Best Pepperoni

dips, drizzles & dressings
$2 / 3 for $5 (4 oz.)

NICK’S HOT HONEY

GARLIC BOMB*

HOUSE ITALIAN*

HOUSE RANCH*

RIPPER RANCH*

*Available Vegan

OHIO STYLE COOKIES
$3.50 each
or 2 for $6

Maybe the best cookies in the world. Small batch,

baked fresh IN-HOUSE daily. Flavors rotate regularly.

MEDIUM box
(9 cookies) $25

LARGE box
(16 cookies) $40

*Cookie flavors must be selected in store (there are way too many flavors to read over the phone)